Why G must never hand over all CPF

If one needs only ONE reason why our Government must stand firm against all assault on the CPF Minimum Sum scheme, then the widow from Skudai who squandered $1 million (MR2.5million) in just 12 months is that very reason. (See full story below)

OK, perhaps this example has come to light at a fortuitous time when people with little money sense are pushing to get their hands on some real money of their own. Or perhaps this example has been dug up by parties who want to deliver a lesson to those who don’t know better. No matter. Because the example ain’t a made-up story. It’s something that can and will happen to those falling into the category of the proverb “a fool and his money are soon parted”.

Those who agitate against G keeping the minimum sum and turning it into CPF Life and yet at the same time cry that their CPF savings aren’t enough to see them through their twilight years are talking from both sides of their mouths.

So if you don’t have enough CPF to last you till your last day, then taking out whatever little you have is going to change matters, izzit?

What kind of muddled thinking is this, especially for the 50% of CPF members on the verge of retirement who are said to have less than the stipulated MS!

If the Skudai widow can get through a million bucks in 12 months, how long do you think $60K or $70K is going to last folks who got so little in their self-managed POSB accounts that they hanker after what little they have in their CPF!

At least Madam Pusparani has youth on her side. She has decades ahead of her to redeem her expensive mistake. Not so the Singaporean retiree drooling for his CPF pennies.

So unless we want to see ancient tissue-paper sellers, homeless elderly folks and charity meals and shelters become growth industries in Singapore, please Mr Prime Minister, say NO to any liberalisation of the Minimum Sum. 👿

Two years ago, after her husband was killed in a freak accident while working at Changi Airport’s Budget Terminal, she received nearly $1 million in insurance payouts and donations from the public. Today, that money is all gone.

Madam Pusparani Mohan, 34, is now looking for work in Singapore to support her four young children back in Johor Baru.

“I made a mistake. People knew I had so much money and they all came to me. I am so stupid. I never buy house and finished all the money meant for my children,” Madam Pusparani told The Sunday Times from her home in Skudai.

She gave some of it away to relatives when she returned to her hometown in Kedah, then spent a portion of it on a holiday in Genting Highlands with her family. She also lost a chunk of it to a bad business investment – all in the span of a year. “Now I don’t have enough for my children’s future.”

On March 17, 2012, her husband, Mr Chandra Mogan Panjanathan, 34, was operating a floor-scrubbing machine outside the terminal when he was hit by a taxi hijacked by a Chinese national.The driver is now serving his jail sentence of two years and one month for voluntarily causing hurt in committing robbery.

Donations poured in after the tragic accident was reported in the media. Many sympathised with Madam Pusparani, who was also working as a cleaning supervisor at the airport, for having to raise four children by herself.The Malaysian couple’s youngest daughter was barely three months old then. Today, their children are aged two, seven, 10 and 11.

Changi Airport Group (CAG) helped to collect donations after it received calls from members of the public wanting to help. Madam Pusparani said she is not clear how much was collected, but thinks it could be about $800,000. She also received over $100,000 in insurance payouts, she said.

“The CAG financial adviser advised me to divide the money between myself and my four children. After allocating $200,000 to each of my four children, I was left with $150,000,” she said. She took that $150,000 home to Johor Baru, quitting her job in Singapore, to take care of her children.

A CAG spokesman told The Sunday Times the CAG had arranged for a family counsellor for Madam Pusparani and had also engaged a financial services adviser to help her with the money she received, including setting up an annuity plan for her children.

“I was told not to touch my children’s money as it was meant for their future,” she said, adding that the financial adviser also suggested she could use the remaining money to set up a small business in Malaysia.

But the money proved too much for Madam Pusparani to manage on her own. She said she first had to pay off debts of $50,000 – the couple, who made $2,000 a month jointly, had borrowed money from friends to make ends meet.

Then, she decided to invest the remaining $100,000 in her brother’s transport business in Kuala Lumpur, thinking it would give her a stable income.

“But I was told the money was only enough to buy one lorry and we needed three lorries. So, I withdrew half of my children’s money, which was about $400,000, to buy two more lorries.”

Madam Pusparani said CAG was unaware of the withdrawal as the money was kept in an account under her name.”I was thinking I could put the money back later,” said Madam Pusparani, her voice shaking.

The business did make money in the first three months, said Madam Pusparani, who has a Sijil Pelajaran Malaysia, the equivalent of an O-level certificate, and who took up accounting as she wanted to manage the business herself.

But in the fourth month, the widow was told that the company was losing money. She said she fell out with her brother eventually and did not recover any of her investment.

Her younger brother, Mr Magan Mohan, 32, a technician, said she blamed the family for encouraging her to invest in the business. Mr Magan said his elder brother’s business has since folded.”Some people think my sister gambled away the money, but she never gambles or drinks. She just got into the wrong business.”

In January last year, Madam Pusparani took out the rest of the money meant for her children. She had no choice, she said.”I never work, but I have to eat. I also need to take care of my parents. I was living with them and I had to pay for the monthly rental which was about RM1,000. My baby is still young and needs money for milk and pampers,” said Madam Pusparani, agitatedly.”My expenses came up to RM5,000 to RM6,000. Where do I find the money?”

That last $400,000 she withdrew lasted her five months. By May last year, she was broke.”I also don’t know how I finished (using) the money,” she said.

A friend got her a job as an accounts clerk in Johor Baru, earning RM2,000 (S$780) a month.Today, her employer pays her rent for an old, double-storey terraced house, which her family of five live in. A huge portrait of the late Mr Chandra is the only thing adorning the empty living area.

Her children’s shoes are torn and worn out; so too are their schoolbags.The family sleeps on two old mattresses in one of three rooms on the second storey. Clothes are piled up on the floor as they cannot afford a cupboard to keep them in.

“I cannot survive with RM2,000 a month. I am thinking of going to work in Singapore. But I feel ashamed,” said Madam Pusparani tearfully.”I don’t know how to explain to the people who donated money to me and my children.”

– See more at: http://www.straitstimes.com/news/singapore/more-singapore-stories/story/1m-gone-2-years-widow-now-broke-20140608#sthash.R6wwL68R.dpuf

Advertisements

11 thoughts on “Why G must never hand over all CPF

  1. Pingback: Daily SG: 9 Jun 2014 | The Singapore Daily

  2. Isn’t this a good example of not throwing good money, giving it away or to let a stranger manage it without any transparency or accountability but to spend it yourself?

  3. /// OK, perhaps this example has come to light at a fortuitous time when people with little money sense are pushing to get their hands on some real money of their own. ///

    Fortuitous? Don’t you know the running dogs leave nothing to chance? The presstitudes push out this article to brown-nose the power-that-be since CPF is the hot-button issue right now. Brownie points for you……..

  4. Xmen, since u r so persistent, I will allow yr link.

    In my view, people kill themselves for all sorts of reasons. I can give you at least 10 reasons unrelated to CPF but have refrained since I don’t know the deceased.

    The curious thing you may want to ponder is this: if he was 57 and had $200K in his CPF, he would have more than enough to cover the current minimum sum requirements. And he would have been allowed to withdraw the difference! So why didn’t he? Tell me?

    Btw, CPF is actually your best shelter against your creditors. Even if you are bankrupt, they can’t touch your CPF money, so long as you leave it there. Geddit? 👿

  5. THE?? So what if they surface the story to make a point? Something I had also raised as a possibility. Timing of the publication can’t negate the fact that it is a true story.

    The only thing you have the right to make a song and dance about is IF the story is untrue. Geddit? 👿

  6. Say Cheese: Don’t come to this blog again if you want to talk nonsense. Create your own blog n do your own IMH things there.

    CPF isn’t a stranger to those of us sane and decent-minded members, thank you!

  7. Aunt Lucia

    Good morning and a good week to you.
    My commiserations and suggest no attention to The/Saycheese/Xmen when they are in their woe is me or victimology mode.
    At the end of the day, they expect the govt to be all powerful and give all their wants not just their needs same as the bumiputra mentality irrespective of their own decisions contributing at times to their own situations.
    Have a good day

  8. Thank you Uncle Wang. Trust you to drop by to help sweeten the atmosphere. I don’t mind those dudes (duds??) dropping by and giving enlightening comment. But I draw the line when they just make use of my blog to amplify their nonsense. 🙄

  9. Pingback: The CPF Conundrum | Inenet Consultancy Pte Ltd

  10. Pingback: CPF & uncharted waters | FOOD fuels me to talk...

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s