Let him without fear, cast the 1st stone

OK, folks, this isn’t an apologia for what happened at the nursing home in Braddell Road.

Rather, I want to pose a question to all those high-minded souls prescribing 1,001 things that must be done to keep our nursing homes safe, their staff in Florence Nightingale mode 24/7 and those elderly folks — parents or other close relatives whom we have no choice but to outsource to others for care — under constant TLC.

How many of you have spent an hour as a visitor to a nursing home — usually an euphemism for a place for people needing care in most things that well-people do for themselves without a second thought? Such as brushing your teeth, bathing, going to the toilet, even eating and drinking, getting up and sitting down, putting on and taking off clothes, shoes etc etc

How many of you have spent 2 hours at a stretch? 3 hours? A regular visitor? A daily visitor?

I think I have spent more time in nursing or old folks homes than the average adult Singaporean without a parent or other kin in one or isn’t a kindly volunteer or medical or nursing home professional.

I’ve done so not out of choice but because of “duty” thrusted upon me.

It was years ago, when I was working in a company where the boss made it an annual ritual to visit many such homes: not the commercial kind but those run by charities and the state.

Our visits were well notified in advance. My boss was a VVIP and would bring an entourage of helpers including — besides his own staff — friends of his who were VIP in their own right. Media were sometimes in tow.

It would therefore be suicidal for those running the charity and state homes to show anything but their “best” side.

All the homes we visited were tidy, clean and occasionally even managed to rise above the general shabbiness synonymous with institutionalised living: at least those areas we were given access to and those inmates well enough to eat the dinner provided and receive their individual hongbao.

So while those homes weren’t places we, the visitors, aimed to trundle to in our twilight years, they were places which all of us felt OK to send those without kith or kin once they are passed their use-by date.

Then I had a rude awakening. It was on my last visit to one such home for the destitute, as I was leaving the employ of the VVIP. That home thankfully no longer exists. It was somewhere out in Woodlands when Woodlands was truly out in the boondocks and MRT was but a twinkle in our planners’ eye.

As I’m not a natural do-gooder, I had found those annual charity excursions something to endure than enjoy.

That being my last visit I felt at liberty to skip the group hongbao distribution and checking on the catered food paid for by the VVIP. I wandered off the beaten path to somewhere right at the back of the home.

That’s when I saw a sight which stunned me. It might have been a scene straight from One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest. 

Those were days pre-dating the Internet, digicams, fone cams and web cams.

So, I’ve nothing to support me other than my memory.

There were two cadaver-like figures, not lying prone and yet not sitting up on what I would call wooden pallets on some metal frames. They were naked as the day they were born. Two orderlies were hosing them down. I could see from riverlets of dirty water spreading on the ground that the two hapless elderlies must have dirtied themselves.

I beat a hasty retreat as I didn’t want to linger over so disturbing a scene.

I wish i could record that I told the home’s benefactor what I saw. Or shared with the others in his entourage.

I did neither but kept wishing that I hadn’t wandered off. Then I won’t have put myself in the terrible quandary of having to decide whether to tell or not.

I kept quiet when I rejoined the entourage as those were the days when junior staff didn’t normally pipe up unless specifically invited to.

What I did do on returning to the bosom of my family was to tell my folks and felt comforted that the general opinion was that the destitute were better off in a state home than dirty, starving and dying on a street corner, open to the elements.

Fast forward three decades.

The Braddell Road nursing home incident surfaced. The son who did the secret video-taping has since back-tracked somewhat, following the overwhelming publicity. He appears now to say the slap was an affectionate pat; his motivation he claims is to encourage his elder brother to take his mother out of the home and let her stay with him, the younger brother.

Convoluted story. Whatever.

But if all the hand wringers’ prescriptions in reaction to the incriminating video — as reflected in the Straits Times’ Forum — were to be followed, then those with loved ones in nursing homes need, nay must, be prepared to spend more than the  average of  $1,050 that’s charged by the Braddell Road home.

Would Singaporeans be willing to pay more for better care, better facilities? Would they pay for a 1-to-2 care ratio or even a 2-to-1 ratio? If not, would the state supplement, besides putting in all the etxra checks that newly-minted Health Minister Gan Kim Yong has promised?

Civil servant Oh Ping Huat, 25, told the Straits Times that the work attitude of the staff at the affected home — his father stayed there for about four months while his home is being renovated — was no different from that of those at other homes.

“My father complained that when he asked them to help, like bring a cup of water, they would take their own sweet time,” he said.

“But I have experience with other nursing homes; it’s also this kind of standard. Certain nurses are willing to do more; I can’t expect all nurses to be hardworking.”

Realistic and pragmatic.

In addition, elderly healthcare practitioners say that nursing staff need to be properly trained to deal with elderly patients, especially those with mental health issues.

Ng Wai Chong, 42, assistant director at the Tsao Foundation’s Hua Mei Mobile Clinic, said, “Perhaps we need to take another look at our strategy in the long run for community care so that families don’t have to send as many people to nursing homes.”

Bingo! That’s the nub!

I know a senior medical specialist whose clinic at Mt Elizabeth Medical Centre used to be always packed with patients, local and foreign. Mention his name and everyone in the medical profession would know him.

Yet the latest I hear about him from my good friend — his niece — is since his retirement his mental state has deteriorated to a level where he needs two shifts of nursing care, at home. His moods are erratic and he is prone to violence. As he is still mobile, picture the havoc he can wreak when the spirit takes him! Consequently, family members, especially his wife, live under tremendous stress.

His isn’t the only case I know about.

Sitting down with friends and family members of my age group, we are increasingly alarmed by stories when we hear about our seniors or even contemporaries — at school and work — who though once holding prestigious positions in their careers and society have now, in old age, descended into a living hell that emcompasses their families as well.

And these are the lucky ones whose families have the capacity, mental and financial, to keep them at home. Think of the tens of thousands not so fortunate 😥

Unless Singapore takes a more holistic approach to planning for the fast approaching silver tsunami, then what happened at the Braddell home may be par for the course not too far down the road 😥


6 thoughts on “Let him without fear, cast the 1st stone

  1. I blamed the gov for some of these problems. I know, everyone will say, ‘everything also blame the gov’. Look at it this way, the people who start these nursing home are also business men, they also want to make a profit. The gov can give all kinds of incentive to those MNC to start up in sg and make and repatriate profits. Do they give any incentive to business man in sg to start good quality nursing homes? as far as i know the lease is 30 years, who would want to start one? with the aging population, are the gov anticipating and encouraging nursing homes? they only want to send the old folks to JB. why? because the nursing homes do not make $$$$ for the gov. the gov should give more incentives to the start up of these homes and in return make them give better quality care and price.

  2. Next thing we know, maid fall out of window, blame the government for not subsiding the maid agencies so that they can train the maids.

    Government investment in strategic area of business or industry is usually for good reasons. Like bringing in MNC and granting them certain benefits (not investments). These MNC creates jobs and provide business opportunities for the SME which in turn provides more jobs for their staff. Having these MNC based here will also attract other MNC and supporting industries to move here. In the long run the economy, people and Country will benefit from having them here.

    Investing and subsidizing nursing home? Will that help to improve the quality of care for the residents? I seriously doubt it. The homes charged a resident an average of $1500.00 pm and yet pay their staff $400 – $600 a month. The staff resident ratio as I understand is an average miserable 1: 12 in most privately run homes. So where did the money goes to? Into the pocket of these businessmen who set up these homes. Government subsidy is merely only going to enrich them further instead of improving it. Look at the child care industries and you will know what I mean.

  3. Not Convinced & Tekko: IMHO, I think you are both wrong.

    The Govt can’t look after everyone in their old age, or even a 50%. The Govt didn’t ask us to be born for heaven’s sake, even tho in current circumstances of BB bonus, it seems to be doing so which then might make for a gd argument to try to extract cradle to grave support… something that only a wholly state controlled country cld deliver. Mayb we shld all go back to embrace communism?

    As for nursing homes making money: it’s hard earned, heart breaking $. On top of that, have to pay for property which as anyone knows, it costs an arm n a leg in Sg! Uncle Tekko, $1.5K a month is a drop in the ocean to care for a sick elderly. That’s why operators cut corners. If it’s so lucrative, nursing homes will be like tuition centres! Critics shld run a pilot project n see for themselves… 🙄

  4. Mayb we shld all go back to embrace communism?

    as much as people complain about income gaps, this is surely the worst solution to capitalism! 😛

    basically, i agree that people are just not prepared to pay for good quality healthcare for their aged relatives! many expect it to be cheap and good! auntielucia should read angrydoc!

  5. AL

    For all those who advocate communism, let me reiterate that most would not be happy for the one simple reason, envy and manmade decisions.

    During the socalled pure period in which in China, during cultural revolution, everybody gets ration coupons, the reality were that since leaders distribute the coupons, they were by decree entitled to additional coupons.
    So what happened than you can guess due to human greed and desire.


  6. Hi Quirky n Wang-Wang: Don’t dismiss communism off hand! At it’s most idealistic (n impractical), it advocated “From each according to his ability, to each according to his need”. 🙄

    Worked to its logical conclusion, it means that most of the resources of a country would be directed to the weakest in society while the strongest will be working their butts off and yet consume only what they need, which being strong infers it will be less than those disabled in body or mind.

    That’s what many Sgporeans seem to clamouring for the way they say the state (govt) shld provide for this this, that and perhaps even the new Woodlands water tank. Of cos they don’t call it communism, but caring and sharing.

    The reality is that unless the strongest in everything are masochists, they won’t buy either the communist, socialist or caring framework, except via minimal mandated tax and emotive philanthropy.

    Any Govt that squeezes too hard on the high income will soon be left with lemons. Perhaps the less able can make lemonade? 😆

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s